Undernews is the online report of the Progressive Review, edited by Sam Smith, who has covered Washington during all or part of one quarter of America's presidencies and edited alternative journals since 1964. The Review has been on the web since 1995. See main page for full contents

January 26, 2009


Richard Silverstein, Tikun Olam - Haaretz brings news that Israel and Hamas are in the midst of serious negotiations under Egyptian auspices over a long-term truce. According to the report, Israel has proposed up to a 10 year truce while Hamas has countered with a one-year offer. As part of its offer, Israel would be willing to lift its 18-month blockade of Gaza:

"Egypt is also demanding a truce of a number of years' duration. But Taha, Hamas' spokesman in the Gaza Strip, said the group would agree to a cease-fire of no more than between one year and 18 months. Another Hamas spokesman, Ismail Radwan, said a long-term cease-fire 'kills' the right to resistance by the Palestinians."

Part of the negotiation involves how to monitor the borders in a way that is acceptable to both Israel and Hamas. The presence of Israeli or Fatah monitors at the crossings is a sensitive one for Hamas as Israel in the past has used its presence to force the closing of the border for reasons that were less than transparent. . .

If true (and its important to note that hopeful reports like this often turn out to be empty ones), this is a most welcome development as it provides hope of a more stable relationship between Hamas and Israel. This also indicates that Israel is negotiating with Hamas (albeit indirectly), something which Israel and the U.S. have taken great pains to claim they would never do.

Nowhere in this report is there any mention of Hamas recognizing Israel, which was another one of the supposedly "non-negotiable" principles that Israel and the U.S. demanded before it would negotiate with or recognize Hamas. One might even see the Israeli proposal for an unlimited or even 10 year truce as creeping toward Hamas' own position, which publicly offered a long term hudna to Israel, a proposal that has been on the table for some time and rejected previously by Israel.

If the story is correct, it also proves that Israel's vaunted claim that it invaded in order to silence Hamas rockets was for naught. Just as the Jewish peace camp has claimed all along, the only thing that will silence the rockets is negotiations-each side compromising and giving up on something it considers important in order to get from the other side something it considers even more important. . .

All this will give George Mitchell something substantive to talk about with Olmert, Barak and Livni when he arrives on Wednesday.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

I would not trust anything that Jihad Richard reports!
Capostein supports Hamas and Hizbbolah.

January 26, 2009 4:33 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I found this on another blog, very funny.

The Little Dickie Silverstein Marching Song

I am a little kapo,
It makes my mommy mad,
Cause when I am a kapo,
Those Zionists get sad!

I celebrate the jihad,
and terror all the while,
I fill my blog and web page,
With loud salutes of Sieg Heil!

I want to see them Zraelis,
All dumped out in the sea,
My swastika a waving,
Cause everything’s bout me.

January 29, 2009 1:04 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home