Undernews is the online report of the Progressive Review, edited by Sam Smith, who has covered Washington during all or part of one quarter of America's presidencies and edited alternative journals since 1964. The Review has been on the web since 1995. See main page for full contents

March 6, 2009


Good - No matter how speedily our cars are able to go, we still find ourselves sitting in heaps of traffic-stopped, cranky, and cursing the slow truck in front of us. But according to Audrey Dussutour of Universite Paul Sabatier in Toulouse, France, we would do well to take a few cues from ants, who, in spite of Dussutour 's best efforts, never get stuck in traffic. She offered an explanation . . .

GOOD: What do you mean when you say ants don't get stuck in traffic?

AUDREY DUSSUTOUR: I've done lots of experiments trying to fool them or create traffic jams, but I've never really succeeded because they always find a solution to avoid it on the trail. They just change the rules. . .

For my paper I was working with Isca ants, and they carry food, like big leaves. The ants that carry food are slower; the ants who are behind have to adjust their speed to the loading ants. But it's funny-and quite unexpected-they never try to overtake the loading ants, even if the loading ants were very slow. Because the loading ants are always given the right of way on the trail, if the others just stay behind the loading ants, they took the benefit of that too.

G: So by going more slowly, they actually collectively went faster?

AD: Right. But, it doesn't work with cars. If you are on a highway behind a slow truck, you probably overtake them each time.

G: Yes, the slow truck doesn't automatically get the right of way. Does that mean ants are just more cooperative than we are?

AD: Yeah, they are co-operative, but I don't know if they know what they are doing. . .

G: How else do they avoid traffic?

AD: The ants always select the best way to go. Imagine the ants have two roads. One is very short but it is very narrow too-so it is going to be overcrowded very quickly-and one road is very wide but very long. When the flow is very low, they always take the short road, but as soon as it gets overcrowded, they move to the long branch, so they don't lose time. So ants are more flexible in a way. Because ants have no rules, there is no boss somewhere saying, "you go there, you go there." It is more self organized. And humans are exactly the opposite. We have laws in traffic.

G: How do we apply this knowledge to human traffic problems?

AD: Just remove the rules and it would work. I'm kidding, but if you look at videos from the south of Asia, Thailand, or India, sometimes traffic doesn't seem to have any rules, but it works very well, and has a very nice flow. It is like bikes and trucks, and pedestrians. It looks scary from our point of view, because we are not used to that. But if it looks like it works, why interfere? But, in fact, the ants can collide. They can really bump into each other with no harm to anybody. But with humans it would be more difficult.


Anonymous Justice said...

Uncle Al thought about ants, too:

"Darwin's theory of the struggle for existence and the selectivity connected with it has by many people been cited as authorization of the encouragement of the spirit of competition. Some people also in such a way have tried to prove pseudo-scientifically the necessity of the destructive economic struggle of competition between individuals. But this is wrong, because man owes his strength in the struggle for existence to the fact that he is a socially living animal. As little as a battle between single ants of an ant hill is essential for survival, just so little is this the case with the individual members of a human community."

"Perfection of means and confusion of goals seem - in my opinion - to characterize our age."

"If we desire sincerely and passionately the safety, the welfare, and the free development of the talents of all men, we shall not be in want of the means to approach such a state. Even if only a small part of mankind strives for such goals, their superiority will prove itself in the long run."
-Albert Einstein 1879 - 1955

March 7, 2009 8:38 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home